logo
  • About Us
        • About us about us
        • A Premier Business School in Asia with Global Influence
        • Overview
          • Message from the Dean
          • Vision & Mission
          • Milestones
          • Partnership & Global Network
          • Beta Gamma Sigma HKU Chapter
          • Rankings & Accreditations
          • Corporate Collaboration
        • Leadership
          • Faculty Management
          • International Advisory Council
        • Contact Us
        • Staff Portal
        • Campuses
  • Programmes
        • Programmes programmes
        • Diversified Learning Experience Empowers our Students
        • Undergraduate
        • Masters
          • MAcct
          • MEcon
          • MFin
          • MFFinTech
          • MGM
          • MSc(BA)
          • MScMktg
        • MBAs & EMBAs
          • MBA
          • IMBA
          • EMBA-Global Asia
          • HKU EMBA
        • PhD
        • Executive Education
        • DBA
  • People
        • People people
        • International Faculty Body that Offers Quality Education
        • Faculty
        • Post-Doctoral Fellows
        • Demonstrators/ Teaching Assistants
        • Research Postgraduate Students
        • Administration
  • Research
        • Research research
        • Lead the Frontier of Knowledge Creation
        • Thought Leadership
          • Latest Research Publications
          • Research Insights
          • Impact Stories
          • HKEJ Column
          • In the Media
          • Global Scholars
        • Academic Areas
        • Faculty Members
        • Research Grants
        • Seminars & Conferences
          • Edward K Y Chen Distinguished Lecture Series
        • Research Centres & Institutes
        • Hong Kong Macroeconomics Forecast
        • HKU Knowledge Exchange
        • HKU Scholars Hub
  • Events
  • Media
        • Media media
        • Inspire the Society and Community with Rigorous Insights
        • School News
        • In the Media
        • Press Release
  • Career
        • Career career
        • Fostering Strategic Partnerships and Talent Development
        • Recruit our Talents
        • Student Career Development
        • Career Opportunities
          • Faculty Recruitments
          • HKU Career Site
  • 繁
  • 简
Type To Search
logo
Type To Search
  • About Us
        • About us about us
        • A Premier Business School in Asia with Global Influence
        • Overview
          • Message from the Dean
          • Vision & Mission
          • Milestones
          • Partnership & Global Network
          • Beta Gamma Sigma HKU Chapter
          • Rankings & Accreditations
          • Corporate Collaboration
        • Leadership
          • Faculty Management
          • International Advisory Council
        • Contact Us
        • Staff Portal
        • Campuses
  • Programmes
        • Programmes programmes
        • Diversified Learning Experience Empowers our Students
        • Undergraduate
        • Masters
          • MAcct
          • MEcon
          • MFin
          • MFFinTech
          • MGM
          • MSc(BA)
          • MScMktg
        • MBAs & EMBAs
          • MBA
          • IMBA
          • EMBA-Global Asia
          • HKU EMBA
        • PhD
        • Executive Education
        • DBA
  • People
        • People people
        • International Faculty Body that Offers Quality Education
        • Faculty
        • Post-Doctoral Fellows
        • Demonstrators/ Teaching Assistants
        • Research Postgraduate Students
        • Administration
  • Research
        • Research research
        • Lead the Frontier of Knowledge Creation
        • Thought Leadership
          • Latest Research Publications
          • Research Insights
          • Impact Stories
          • HKEJ Column
          • In the Media
          • Global Scholars
        • Academic Areas
        • Faculty Members
        • Research Grants
        • Seminars & Conferences
          • Edward K Y Chen Distinguished Lecture Series
        • Research Centres & Institutes
        • Hong Kong Macroeconomics Forecast
        • HKU Knowledge Exchange
        • HKU Scholars Hub
  • Events
  • Media
        • Media media
        • Inspire the Society and Community with Rigorous Insights
        • School News
        • In the Media
        • Press Release
  • Career
        • Career career
        • Fostering Strategic Partnerships and Talent Development
        • Recruit our Talents
        • Student Career Development
        • Career Opportunities
          • Faculty Recruitments
          • HKU Career Site
HKU Business School
  • About Us
    • Overview
      • Message from the Dean
      • Vision & Mission
      • Milestones
      • Partnership & Global Network
      • Beta Gamma Sigma HKU Chapter
      • Rankings & Accreditations
      • Corporate Collaboration
    • Leadership
      • Faculty Management
      • International Advisory Council
    • Campuses
    • Contact Us
    • Staff Portal
  • Programmes
    • Undergraduate
    • Masters
      • MAcct
      • MEcon
      • MFin
      • MFFinTech
      • MGM
      • MSc(BA)
      • MScMktg
    • MBAs & EMBAs
      • MBA
      • IMBA
      • EMBA-Global Asia
      • HKU EMBA
    • DBA
    • PhD
    • Executive Education
  • People
    • Faculty
    • Post-Doctoral Fellows
    • Demonstrators/ Teaching Assistants
    • Research Postgraduate Students
    • Administration
  • Research
    • Thought Leadership
      • Latest Research Publications
      • Research Insights
      • Impact Stories
      • HKEJ Column
      • In the Media
      • Global Scholars
    • Academic Areas
    • Faculty Members
    • Research Grants
    • Seminars & Conferences
      • Edward K Y Chen Distinguished Lecture Series
    • Research Centres & Institutes
    • Hong Kong Macroeconomics Forecast
    • HKU Knowledge Exchange
    • HKU Scholars Hub
  • Events
  • Media
    • School News
    • In the Media
    • Press Release
  • Career
    • Recruit our Talents
    • Student Career Development
    • Career Opportunities
      • Faculty Recruitments
      • HKU Career Site

Research Insights

Home Research Thought Leadership Research Insights

Didn’t Earn It? Return It.

NA
Share on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on WhatsappShare on LinkedInShare on Email

When it comes to compensation, an agent is expected to keep that which they are entitled to – this is a fundamental American value[1]. However, since the infamous WorldCom and Enron scandals which rocked markets in the U.S. and beyond in the early 2000s – where executives of both companies received bonuses based on fraudulent financial statements – compensation recovery provisions, known as “clawbacks”, have been imposed to deter fraud and unlawful risk-taking decision-making by executives of financial service providers.

The WorldCom and Enron scandals were a wake-up call and a red flag for regulators that the system did not prevent executives from misstating their companies’ performance – effectively getting compensation that they should not have received, with no consequences. This red flag was raised higher after the 2007-2008 financial crisis, leading to the enactment of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act – the Dodd-Frank Act for short – in 2010, which brought in sweeping financial regulatory reforms. These affected thousands of listed companies in the United States, representing tens of trillions worth of market capitalisation.

In 2015, the SEC went even further, proposing Rule 10D-1 of the Dodd-Frank Act which aimed to regulate clawback provisions meaning that from 2017, all listed companies would be required to recover excess incentive-based compensation received by an executive officer, if the company had to prepare an accounting restatement to correct serious misconducts like accounting irregularities. This is a fancy way of saying “If you didn’t earn it, you must return it”.

Research conducted at HKU on clawbacks has had a major influence on the SEC’s policymaking process, and has stimulated public debate by offering a holistic discussion on the benefits and shortfalls of clawbacks. The ensuing regulatory reforms have been widely discussed and debated in the media and across the global regulatory community.

Dr Lilian Chan’s research has brought attention to the significance of this subject and the implications on the industry. Her work has revealed a number of insights: that in firms that adopt clawbacks, earnings quality improves, audit fees are lower, auditors are less likely to report material internal control weaknesses, and audit report lags are shorter. Why? Because managers have less incentive to manipulate company earnings when they can anticipate the potential costs to the company, such as the loss of income and reputation.

Dr Chan also discovered that accounting earnings reported by “clawback firms” are more credible and informative from an investor’s point of view; and auditors are more likely to perceive these firms as having lower control risk. Also, the borrowing costs of clawback firms are lower because of better earnings quality.

The research conducted by Dr Chan has not only benefited international scholars, it has had a perceptible effect on the industry itself, documented in the SEC’s rule proposalwhich cites two of Dr Chan’s publications, and public comment which cited her work as grounds to support the proposal.

 

Dr Lilian Chan, Associate Professor in Accounting and Law, HKU Business School, received the Faculty Knowledge Exchange Award in 2019 for the research accomplishments achieved in this knowledge exchange project. She was one of the ten most promising female associate professors selected by the HKU-10 Mentorship Programme 2018-2019, which aimed to unleash the full potential of women academics to become confident, capable leaders and eliminate barriers to their academic leadership success.

 

Sources

[1] Aguilar, L.A. 2015. Statement at an Open Meeting on Dodd-Frank Act “Clawback” Provision. https://www.sec.gov/news/statement/making-executive-compensation-more-accountable-.html

[2] Chan, L.H., K.C.W. Chen, T.-Y.Chen, and Y.Yu. 2012. The effects of firm-initiated clawback provisions on earnings quality and auditor behavior. Journal of Accounting and Economics 54 (2), 180–196. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jacceco.2012.05.001

[3] Chan, L.H., K.C.W. Chen, and T.-Y.Chen. 2013. The effects of firm-initiated clawback provisions on bank loan contracting. Journal of Financial Economics 110, 659–679. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfineco.2013.08.010

[4] Chan, L.H., K.C.W. Chen, T.-Y. Chen, and Y. Yu. 2015. Substitution between real and accruals-based earnings management after voluntary adoption of compensation clawback provisions. The Accounting Review 90 (1), 147–174. https://doi.org/10.2308/accr-50862

[5] Securities and Exchange Commission. 2015. Listing Standards for Recovery of Erroneously Awarded Compensation. File No. S7-12-15. https://www.sec.gov/rules/proposed/2015/33-9861.pdf

[6] Public Citizen. 2015. Comments on Listing Standards for Recovery of Erroneously Awarded Compensation. https://www.sec.gov/comments/s7-12-15/s71215-9.pdf

[7] Adoptions of Clawbacks Tied to Earnings Manipulation. 2015. CFO.com. http://www.cfo.com/accounting-tax/2015/01/adoption-clawbacks-tied-earnings-manipulation

[8] Clawbacks Can Lead to Accounting Gimmicks. 2015. Accounting Today. https://www.accountingtoday.com/news/clawbacks-can-lead-to-accounting-gimmicks

[9] Corporate Financial Weekly. 2015. Study Finds Executive Compensation Clawback Provisions Do Not Eliminate Possible Earnings Manipulation. https://www.corporatefinancialweeklydigest.com/2015/01/articles/litigation/study-finds-executive-compensation-clawback-provisions-do-not-eliminate-possible-earnings-manipulation

[10] The National Law Review. 2015. Hong Kong Study Finds Executive Compensation Clawback Provisions Do Not Eliminate Possible Earnings Manipulation. https://www.natlawreview.com/article/hong-kong-study-finds-executive-compensation-clawback-provisions-do-not-eliminate-po

Helping the Helpers
Big data is rewriting the medical future of millions of people
Trending
How to Recover from Work Stress, According to Science
How to Recover from Work Stress, According to Science
Dr. Bonnie Hayden CHENG
To combat stress and burnout, employers are increasingly offering benefits like virtual mental health support, spontaneous days or even weeks off, meeting-free days, and flexible work scheduling. Despite these efforts and the increasing number of employees buying into the importance of wellness, the effort is lost if you don’t actually recover. So, if you feel like you’re burning out, what works when it comes to recovering from stress? The authors discuss the “recovery paradox” — that when our bodies and minds need to recover and reset the most, we’re the least likely and able to do something about it — and present five research-backed strategies for recovering from stress at work.
05 Jul 2022
Management and Strategy

External Link
Purple Haze, All in My Brain
Purple Haze, All in My Brain
Jian Zhang from the HKU Business School along with authors from the Shanghai Advanced Institute of Finance at Shanghai Jiao Tong University, INSEAD in Singapore and the PBC School of Finance at Tsinghua University, helped to advance understanding of this phenomenon in their recent paper, called Air Pollution, Behavioral Bias, and the Disposition Effect in China. The team studied how air pollution can affect mental health by intensifying a certain type of cognitive bias observed in financial markets.
19 May 2022
Finance
0HKU_3852_2019
About Author
Dr. Lilian Him Lai CHAN

BBA Programme Director

Sign up for upcoming news and events
LinkedIn WeChat Instagram Facebook Weibo Twitter YouTube

©2022, HKU Business School. All Rights Reserved. | Privacy Policy | Web Accessibility Statement